Pansy in the Great Hall WAS: Re: Dark Book

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 177014

Nita:
<SNIP>
> I mean, honestly, did anyone perceive Pansy as an effective threat?
> She wasn't even trying to *do* anything! <SNIP>

Alla:

I did. There was no way of knowing for me that some of her classmates 
would not carry that threat into action.



> > Jen: As long as no Slytherins opposed Pansy then yes, they are 
> > considered supportive of her agenda.  
> 
> Nita:
> 
> How so? Pansy didn't suggest joining Voldemort. She suggested
> accepting his ultimatum. There's no way to tell why she did that, 
but
> I think the chances that she believed his threats and promises, and
> then chose the obviously (for her) lesser of two evils, are pretty 
good.
<SNIP>

Alla:

Not Jen, but to me it is absolutely same thing as suggest to join 
Voldemort, because accepting his ultimatum - giving him Harry, means 
pretty much Voldemort wins to me anyways.

So, yes, to me it is suggesting joining Voldemort.

Alla.