Re; What is in the box

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 177087

> Potioncat wrote in
> <http://groups.yahoo.com/group/HPforGrownups/message/176957>:
> 
> << What event that must have happened off page, whether or not it 
was
> described, is one you'd like to read? So? What would you be looking
> for? >>

Catlady wrote: 
> My answer is approximately the same as Alla's. The event I would 
want
> to read is The Prank. Some people want to read it to find out 
whether
> Sirius was being an attempted murderer or just an idiot. I'm 
certain
> he was being just an idiot, but I'm very curious how he induced
> Severus to go down the tunnel.

Alla:

Right, I am certain as well that he was being an idiot, but besides 
being extremely curious how he induced Snape to go down to the 
tunnel and why why Snape listened to him, that is not the whole 
reason why I would want to read it.

It is just, I do not know, this whole scene is one of the most 
intense scenes among many many books I read.

Not only it is intense, it remains for me to be vague even after 
series ended, meaning that I cannot construct the whole picture in 
my mind.

I mean, I can but I do not know if it will be the same as what 
author intended.

I mean, stupidity, heroism, curiosity, obnoxiousness - everything, 
everything I can see there and at the same time, I cannot, because 
it is not written.

Oh man, I hope she at least says more in the encyclopedia.


Catlady:
> And what I would be looking for all through the manuscript is 
anything
> that can be taken as evidence for the Sirius/Remus ship.
<SNIP>

Alla:

Sigh. I wish ... I knew I could not get Sirius/ Snape in canon, LOL, 
so I grew to love Sirius/Remus too. Sigh.

Alla