Trelawney Award, part II

[Carol]

No: HPFGUIDX 177229

Bart wrote:
> In DH, what was the major event(s) that made you say, "I didn't see
THAT one coming!" 
> 
> To give my example:
> 
> Snape being friends with Lily BEFORE Hogwarts. It certainly made a
lot of sense in 20/20 hindsight, but I did not see that one coming at
all. 

Carol responds:

I didn't buy into the Snape/Lily SHIP at all, thinking that Snape's
motivations were more complex. Another major event I didn't see coming
was Snape as headmaster (and the whole DE takeover of the MoM). I
thought that Snape, not Harry, would be Undesirable Number One.

Carol, who did believe that Nagini was a Horcrux and that "Severus,
please" meant, "Severus, please kill me," and, erm, well, didn't get
much else right except Harry's self-sacrifice and survival