OOP Chapter 2 Post DH look

Zara zgirnius at yahoo.com
Sat Apr 12 21:09:03 UTC 2008


No: HPFGUIDX 182500

> > zgirnius:
> > For this reason, I presume he never used a Patronus to communicate
> with the Order. We never see him do so. In OotP, he could have left 
the 
> > school grounds to Apparate to 12 GP in person.
 
> Pippin:
> As a general rule, I agree. But that night the patronus could have
> delivered its message to Tonks, who would not have known its
> significance, or directly to Sirius, who died before he could 
discuss
> it with anyone.

zgirnius:
It could have, but I do not believe that it did. Snape could not 
count on anyone other than Sirius taking the first message (why would 
Tonks be there on a workday afternoon?), and he could not count on 
Sirius dying, since Snape had no reason to believe Sirius would 
shortly be getting himself killed.

It seems to me that even Albus was unaware of the form taken by 
Snape's Patronus, so I really do not think he used it to send 
messages to anyone.







More information about the HPforGrownups archive