Hogwarts classes and textbooks
Jerri/Dan Chase
danjerri at madisoncounty.net
Wed Apr 23 02:09:00 UTC 2008
No: HPFGUIDX 182625
All the discussions of Harry's academic abilities (or lack thereof)
and how the students who attended Hogwarts learned the basics like
reading and maths (which I recall JKR said that some went to muggle
elementary type schools and others were home schooled), has reminded
me of a question in my mind about one of the classes that Harry and
apparently all Hogwart's students took every year for the first 5
years of school. And that is Astronomy.
And my question is:
Why do they take Astronomy, for FIVE years, when there is so much
other stuff that they don't have time to study?
I don't recall every seeing anyone USE astronomy. In divination there
is some mention of plant and star movements, and they having learned
things in astronomy. But not everyone takes divination, and the
astronomy related parts of divination are small, except perhaps when
taught by a certain replacement teacher!
So, can anyone else find anyplace in the books where astronomy is
used?
That is, any reason for this class except to provide an astronomy
tower, from which Norbert can depart, HRH and friends can see Hagrid's
confrontation with Umbridge's staff, followed by McGonagall's
response, and finally for Dumbledore to fall off?
And, why is Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them a required text
for first year students at Hogwarts, when they don't take Care of
Magical Creatures classes until third year? And isn't it supposed to
be an optional class, even then? Every other book on their list is
directly related to a class.
And if the Weasley family is hard up for money, do they really need a
complete set of Lockhart books for each of their five children at
Hogwarts that year? Can't they share at all?
(By the way, I do own a copy of FB&WTFT and enjoy it a lot, but I do
wonder.)
Jerri
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive