The Malfoys WAS: Wizarding kids and their parents
sistermagpie
sistermagpie at earthlink.net
Sun Aug 3 14:38:24 UTC 2008
No: HPFGUIDX 183958
> Emily here (boy, it's been a loooong time!)
I think at the same time DD is protecting Harry, the Order
> is also sheltering Ron and Hermione. Ron would be there anyway, but
> could they really send Hermione back to her Muggle parents and let
> Voldemort just pick her off? Additionally, there is the matter of
> protecting her parents.
Magpie:
There's no canon to indicate that Hermione's parents are going to
picked off, and if Voldemort was after them Hermione herself being
safe at the burrow (not that the burrow is particularly safe if
Voldemort decided to show up) would not protect them.
Hermione stays because she wants to be involved with what's going on
with her friends. And her estrangement from her parents is not just
physical. She's not telling them things that are going on in her life
because they "wouldn't understand." (That she's planning to go skiing
with them means little when she lies to them to blow them off once
something happens with Harry that she wants to be involved in.) So
yeah, I think her relationship with her parents just comes naturally
out of the Muggle/Wizard divide and that her attitude about them
reflects the attitudes Wizards have towards Muggles in general.
Emily:
> I think we see some of the great, unselfish love that Hermione has
for
> her parents when she reveals the measures she has taken to protect
> them in DH. She truly just wants them to be safe, and happy, so
much
> so that she's willing to remove her memory from them and send them
> away so that hopefully they will be out of LV's reach.
Magpie:
Oh god, that's a bad example if you're trying to win over those of us
who think she's estranged from them. For a lot of us, that's the
ultimate example of her attitude. Nobody doubts that Hermione loves
her parents. She just doesn't respect them as equals or parents.
They're lucky she didn't turn them into dogs and kennel them for the
duration.
-m
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive