Who WAS the True Master of the Elder Wand?

[jdl3811220]

No: HPFGUIDX 183972

> > Pippin:
> > But Harry had to have some reason to start thinking that
> > *he* might be the master of the Elder Wand, without it
> > being so obvious that the reader would get there first.

> Carol responds:
<SNIP>
> If we had only seen him attempt and fail some spectacular
> feat of magic along the lines of the spells used in the
> duel with Dumbledore in the MoM. So the supposed failure
> of the wand is only an excuse to kill Snape, after which
> Voldemort uses it again to "kill" Harry, casting what
> would have been a successful AK if it weren't for the
> shared drop of blood--nothing to do with the Elder Wand
> (which does not at that point recognize Harry as its master.
<SNIP>

Jenni from Alabama responds:
Now this is just my opinion... but I think that Harry was the
Master of the Elder Wand the entire time. Why? Because Ignotus
Peverell died a natural death! No one defeated him! He was
Master of the Wand. Harry is a descendant of his... a direct
descendant! I think the Wand worked somewhat for Tom because
he was related to the Peverells. But Ignotus was supposedly
Harry's great, great, great (however many greats) grandfather.
The Wand showed its complete loyalty to Harry because of that.
Defeating Draco just solidified it even more.

As to why it worked for Dumbledore... I think that Dumbledore
was also related to the Peverells.

Just my opinion.

Jenni