Who WAS the True Master of the Elder Wand?

[Mike]

No: HPFGUIDX 184013

> Carol:
> -<snip basically whole post>-
> 
> If JKR wanted Voldemort to doubt that he was the master of the
> Elder Wand, she should have given him reason to doubt it--on page,
> with no speculation required by the reader. She failed to do that.
> 
> Carol, who understands exactly what you're saying but does not
> agree with your position

Mike:
OK, I can see that. Another case, for you, of not getting the story on 
page, instead being told to accept the story without proof. We saw 
proof of what the Elder Wand *could* do, but never really saw what the 
Elder Wand *wasn't* doing that convinced Voldemort the thing ain't 
happening for him.

I'm willing to accept that Voldemort could sense the connection wasn't 
there, you are not. That's fair.