Blowing his cover
Zara
zgirnius at yahoo.com
Sun Feb 10 15:15:14 UTC 2008
No: HPFGUIDX 181443
> CJ:
> Even if Harry IS all wound up about his friends and fellow students
> (though, as we've seen, not more than a Stunning spell's worth), then
it
> simply becomes a crime of passion. But a crime of passion is still a
crime.
zgirnius:
Attacking Bella and Snape were also crimes of passion, were they not? I
am arguing this Crucio was no different from the others (aside from the
fact that it worked, and was not blocked by its target
>CJ:
> Nevertheless, we still have Harry's own admission: "He spat at you!"
The
> passage just doesn't support any other interpretation.
zgirnius:
Obviously, I disagree.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive