Mistakes made in Deathly Hallows? The Elder Wand
Jayne
jaynesmith62 at btinternet.com
Mon Feb 11 20:05:57 UTC 2008
No: HPFGUIDX 181474
> bboyminn:
> As to transfer of the Wand, that is equally tricky. You can
> transfer possession without tranferring ownership or
> allegiance. But consider this, many times in its history
> the Wand must have moved from the possession of one wizard
> to another, but not under the right circumstances. Yet, at
> some point the non-Master owner of the wand was defeated
> and the wand transfer it allegiance somehow to the new
> wizard. That complicates thing immensely in my mind.
Going on the point made above, how did Draco become the master
of the wand? When he was with DD on the roof prior to DD death
in HBP, he didn't defeat DD. He used Expelliarmus as DD got to
the roof and the wand fell down. No where in cannon dores it
mention that Draco picked it up. Are we to presume this ?
Hope someone can clear this up for me
Thanks
Jayne
Slightly confused
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive