PoA Ch 10 Post DH look

hp_fan_2008 falkeli at yahoo.com
Tue Feb 12 07:13:47 UTC 2008


No: HPFGUIDX 181488

Bex:
> And the biggest concern of all: How would they [the dementors] know
if they had found Sirius Black, and not some other person? <snip> Did
they have a "emotional footprint" they were looking for? 

HP fan 2008:
It seems to me that the basic thought pattern is the key. Harry was
focusing on Sirius's innocence when the dementor almost kissed him -
exactly the thought that Sirius was focused on at Azkaban. In
addition, when Umbridge sent the dementors to Harry in book 5, I
believe that she wanted them to kiss Harry - but she was completely
wrong about what Harry would be thinking of. Dudley's thought pattern
was probably closer to what Umbridge told the dementors to look for. 





More information about the HPforGrownups archive