[HPforGrownups] Re: Long live the Harry potter series

[Edna Nathan]

No: HPFGUIDX 181522

> Alla:
> <BIG SNIP>
> Yep, I loved all those great moments that you
> listed, but there was 
> little to nothing good about DH?
<BIG SNIP>


I loved the HP series, but COS was my least favorite.
3, 4, 6 & 7 were great. The only people I know who
dislike the series are people who have never read the
books and are judging the movies. I enjoy watching the
movies but they do confuse me on what really happened
in the books so I read them again to refresh my
memory. DH was what I expected it to be and more. I
knew we were going to lose beloved characters in the
big battle. I loved the story of the Peverell Bros. &
the deathly hallows and that Harry is a descendent of
the younger brother. That explains the invisibility
cloak and the mountain of gold in his vault at
Gringott's bank. Aberforth acted like a true sibling.
He pointed out all the faults of his brother as most
siblings do. I was a bit disappointed that the flying
car didn't come out of the forest to join the fight. I
loved that Molly Weasley killed Bellatrix, showing how
fierce a mother's love can be. I loved how Hermione
kept Harry and Ron alive all those months in hiding.
They would surely have died if it wasn't for her
preparedness and quick thinking. Snape? Let's just say
that he's a complicated character. He had a fierce
love for Lily, but he was very unforgiving and cruel.
On the other hand, he was very loyal and brave too.
One doesn't know wether to like or dislike him or
what! I must say that I enjoyed Deathly Hallows very
much.

Edna
Oregon