Wand Lore / Luna / Alchemy

[a_svirn]

No: HPFGUIDX 181666

> > a_svirn wrote:
> 
> >either Dumbledore deliberately set Snape up as a target, or he grew
> >so senile in his old age, that he couldn't even see the obvious
> >consequences of his own actions.
> 
> Jayne:
> IMHO DD did set up Snape as a target. I think he thought it was a 
way
> of protecting Harry and that Snape was a clever enough wizard to 
look
> after him self.
> Shame it went wrong !!!

No shame at all for it went exactly right. If, that is, Dumbledore 
did indeed set Snape as a target. For there is no denying that Snape 
served his purpose as a target. We must congratulate Dumbledore on 
his clever plan. Though I don't quite see in what way it was supposed 
to provide protection for Harry. 

a_svirn.