Warrington and Apparating

[zanooda2]

No: HPFGUIDX 181736

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "l.anne120" <l.anne120 at ...> wrote:

<SNIP>

> But Draco clearly states that Warrington "nearly died" by 
> apparating out of the cabinet and into Hogwarts.  This seems 
> like a clear violation of the magical rules established 
> by JKR.  


Well, the "No-Apparating-in-Hogwarts" rule is not absolute. Remember,
DD lifted the enchantment in the Great Hall for the Apparition lessons
in HBP? It's possible then to lift Hogwarts' anti-Apparition spell, at
least for Apparating inside the castle. 

What I want to say is, that maybe in certain circumstances the spell
can be broken. Maybe the Vanishing Cabinet (being broken and all :-))
created some kind of magical anomaly around itself, so Montague was
able to Apparate when he was on the Hogwarts' side of the limbo :-).
And it's not like he did it easily and safely - you pointed out
yourself that he "nearly died".


zanooda