Respect

[eggplant107]

No: HPFGUIDX 180342

Carol Wrote:

> ALL I'm asking is that JKR respect

So JKR should respect even though you admit you have no respect for
her. Interesting. 

> the right of her readers to interpret
> the books consistently with what's on
> the page throughout the series 

Carol what does that even mean? Even if JK Rowling is the most evil
woman who ever lived how on Earth could she make her readers believe
or do anything?

Geoff Bannister 

> I am a List Elf 

Then it may interest you to know that I have received support for my
views, but all of it has been off list. Why do you suppose that is,
why didn't they send there comments to the group? The only reason I
can think of is that they are afraid to go on record supporting
Rowling in the current atmosphere, and it's not hard to see why. On
more than one occasion I have been told by moderators that I was being
too impolite to other posters for saying some pretty mild things;
certainly I never said I lost all respect for them or the they were an
example of the Peter Principle in action, but when somebody said that
about Rowling there was not a word of protest by anyone except by me.

Hey it's your group not mine and you can run it anyway you want, but
if you don't change your policy might I humbly suggest you change the
name from Harry Potter for Grownups to something a little more
descriptive, like The Rowling Bashers and Harry Hating Mob.

Eggplant