JKR's lesson on prejudice (was:Slytherins come back)
dumbledore11214
dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Tue Jan 8 18:55:01 UTC 2008
No: HPFGUIDX 180480
> >>revaunchanistx:
> What? Did you miss Harry and Draco's meeting in Madam Malkin's
> where Draco oozed prejudice and privilege out of every pore,
> saying half-bloods and mud bloods shouldn't be allowed in and
> my father is trying to get me on the house team and insulted
> Hagrid, Harry's first true friend.
> <snip>
Betsy Hp:
Oh, that's the scene where I first fell in *love* with Draco. Tiny
little thing doing his best to make a new friend and saying *all* the
wrong things. Hilarious *and* poignant. (And I must point out,
Draco said his father thought he *should* be on the quidditch team.
Not that he'd get him on there. Minor point, but a sore-ish one. *g*)
<SNIP>
Alla:
Well, the initial argument was that you spotted right away that Harry
was prejudiced to Draco, no?
And since I agree with revaunchanistx completely, that is what I am
wondering about.
You agree that that tiny little thing in your opinion ( or tiny
prejudiced pureblooded bastard in mine) was saying all the wrong
things, yes?
I say he was saying all prejudicial things to the core (spotting
prejudice and privilege - LOVE and will have to adopt this
expression, hehe). So, where do you get that Harry was prejudiced
towards Draco? I mean if you say he disliked Draco after his speeches
Harry's parents, Harry's first true friend and Harry's second true
friend, I will surely agree with you.
Harry disliked Draco very much after he heard what Draco had to say
on the subject.
What I am wondering is where you see prejudice in Harry's dislike of
Draco?
I see prejudice in calling Harry's dislike prejudice.
Oh, and of course I see nothing wrong in being prejudiced towards the
fictional character, God knows I was told that I am prejudiced
against Slytherins myself many times, LOL and I see nothing wrong
with it. I mean I happened to think that they deserved and especially
Draco deserved all I thought about them and more, but even if I was
prejudiced against fictional character so what.
But if you are saying that you spotted right away that Harry was
prejudiced against Draco, that argument I am not buying.
I think Draco earned every bit of dislike from Harry by insulting
everybody whom Harry liked under the moon in undeserving, prejudicial
way.
JMO,
Alla
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive