JKR's lesson on prejudice (was:Slytherins come back)
Tiffany B. Clark
minnesotatiffany at hotmail.com
Tue Jan 8 19:55:01 UTC 2008
No: HPFGUIDX 180483
> Betsy Hp:
>
> I expected Harry to have to deal with Slytherin as a group of
people rather than an overarching philosophy. I won't say that the
codified prejudice of Slytherin was correct; on the contrary, it was
something that obviously needed fixing. But I also thought
constantly attacking Slytherin, labeling them as the source of all
that was bad in the WW would leave the problem unresolved and
buried. Which, it did, IMO.
Tiffany:
I agree that the overarching philosophy of Harry's helped to
reinforce the negative aspects of Slytherins & justifies maintaining
the status quo about the house as a whole. I personally knew that
Harry was prejudiced since SS & he used Slytherin as a scapegoat,
instead of addressing the real issue on his own. He did have moments
when he had to rethink his ideas on the Slytherin house though & for
that I think he had a huge coming of age moment.
>revaunchanistx:
>
> The only way the status quo would change on a massive scale like you
want it to is through a regime like Voldemort wanted to instill,
where he would have employed tactics that worked in Cambodia,
Stalin's Russia, and Red China and yes even Nazi Germany.
Tiffany:
I saw a lot of connections between those regimes & LV in the canon as
well. I, however, was really impressed by what LV could do early on,
esp. in SS. I've lost some respect for him since because his ego got
in the way a lot, but his knowledge of black magic & the dark arts
has always been awe-inspiring to me.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive