The Sorting Hat - still there?

Lesley McKenna wrappedinharry at yahoo.com.au
Fri Jan 11 10:25:25 UTC 2008


No: HPFGUIDX 180573

--- "sbursztynski" <greatraven@ ...> wrote:

> Did I miss something in my reading or what? Nineteen years 
> after Voldemort destroyed the Sorting Hat, it's still there,
> sorting kids into Houses. Did it get repaired, somehow? Did
> they make a new one - and if so, was it like the old one 
> in taking note of student preferences? Or was it just another
> piece of text that wasn't edited? :-)



My interpretation of why the sorting hat didn't burn was the 
same reason Neville wasn't burnt. I think it is because the 
Elder wand wasn't working properly for Voldemort. None of his 
spells lasted. First of all, he couldn't kill Harry. That was 
partly due to his having Harry's blood in his veins and the 
wand not working. He couldn't keep the crowd quiet when he 
cast a ssilencing charm at them. and the hat didn't burn, 
nor did Neville. 

Just my interpretation.

Lesley/wrappedinharry




More information about the HPforGrownups archive