Lupin's behavior (Was: CHAPDISC: DH11, The Bribe)

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 180583

a_svirn:
<SNIP>
Personally, I think it was the rest of the order who were
irresponsible, sitting on their butts and waiting for three seventeen-
year-olds to do the entire job. At least, Lupin *tried* to do
something. If it wasn't for his fractured relationship with Tonks his
offer would have been perfectly reasonable. <SNIP>

Alla:
Alla:

That's the thing though – his fractured relationship with Tonks to me 
makes **all** the difference.

I want to know what his primary intention is – to run away from his 
wife or to help Trio. I agree with you totally – rest of the order 
was irresponsible, etc. But the thing  is in my mind he IS running 
away from his wife and as means using the Trio.

If he was leaving home happy wife, I mean, not happy that he is 
leaving, but happy otherwise, I would say SURE – he is doing a right 
thing by wanting to help him.

Leaving wife in the time of war – not a problem, I totally 
understand. It is why he is leaving her is a problem for me and 
in "whys" I am inclined to agree with Harry.

JMO,
Alla