Lupin's behavior (Was: CHAPDISC: DH11, The Bribe)

[montavilla47]

No: HPFGUIDX 180619

> Alla:
> 
> Sure, he had no right to be insulting, but does it matter really? I 
> mean if I believe that he had a right to say the essense of what he 
> said, does it make that much of a difference if he said the hurtful 
> things nicely or rudely? Those things ARE still hurtful to Remus but 
> they are also truth in my view.
> 
> The issue is whether Harry had a right to say that Lupin shoud not 
> leave kid and wife, no? If he said it nicely, you would still 
> disagree, right?

Montavilla47:

Alla, Alla!  Don't leave that opening for us!  After all, eighty
percent of the bad!Snape argument is that he says things
in a hurtful manner.

I believe that a further five percent is his unfair points-taking,
and the remaining fifteen percent is the hair?