PS/SS chapters 13-15 post DH look

dumbledore11214 dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Sun Jan 27 15:18:15 UTC 2008


No: HPFGUIDX 181018

> zgirnius:
> The practice Snape assigns to Harry in OotP, as homework for the 
> Occlumency lessons, and Harry never does, is, every night, to 
clear 
> his mind before falling asleep. If a person is sufficiently tired, 
> this may occur naturally if a person just falls into bed and 
sleeps 
> like a log, rather than lying in bed wondering about the events of 
> the day, etc.


Alla:

Could you clarify please what you meant here? I mean I definitely 
thought about Occlumency lessons, but relaxation supposed to be sort 
of opposite to intense Quidditch like training, no?

Or are you saying that had Harry been exercising physically he would 
not have need to close his mind, that would have occurred 
automatically maybe?


Zgirnius:
 (And I can imagine the posts I would have been reading 
> if Snape had made Harry exercise until he was exhausted as part of 
> the lessons, haha!)

Alla:

Snort, oh yeah. I will be the first one to scream - stop abusing him 
you greasy git.

 
> Though I imagine in the long term this wold just make someone 
tired, 
> and make them susceptible during the day, as during Harry's 
History 
> of Magic OWL.

Alla:

Agreed.

> zgirnius:
> I thought this was Voldemort after my first reading of the book. I 
> don't think it necessarily means Quirrell was resisting. More 
likely, 
> he was not getting things done fast enough to please Voldemort. 
(See, 
> e. g., Draco Malfoy crying in bathrooms in HBP).


Alla:

It is Voldemort, if Quirrell speaks the truth in chapter 17. DUH 
Alla one more time.

It is the forgetting such things that makes me want to reread the 
books again and again among other reasons.


Alla






More information about the HPforGrownups archive