Characters' inconsistencies WAS: Re:What did you like about Harry Potter?

[Heather Hadden]

No: HPFGUIDX 183828

Winterfell:
<SNIP>
Also, incidently, for those who crucify Harry for using Crucio
and Imperius spells, I haven't heard too many people after reading DH
who criticized Snape for using the AK curse. It seems to be
inconsistent to criticize Harry and not Snape. They both used
Unforgiveable Curses didn't they? Or would that be ironic? Oh yes,
Snape's was for a good reason, that's right. (And Harry's wasn't?)
<SNIP>

Heather:
No one mentions McGonagall using the Imperius curse on one of the Carrows while in the Ravenclaw common room with Harry and Luna.
 
Heather




[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]