[HPforGrownups] Re: Half-Blood Prince

[Lynda Cordova]

No: HPFGUIDX 183874

I wasn't meaning to be nit picky to Carol. It's neither right nor wrong to
find something like that annoying. It just is one of the many ways people
are different from one another. I've just never seen reason to over ponder
what was obviously (to me) taken care of (Draco's getting a HoG) outside of
the text.  To me, its just one of those things that would have done nothing
but lengthen the books to include and could, in fact be simply mentioned, as
it was, later in the story.
I didn't read anything about JKR having made a mistake about that and it
showing up on the website--I've only visited a dozen times or so--my
internet time doesn't take me to author's webpages often, but, if she did,
and I had realized it, I would have thought, oh she should have changed that
then!, but then let it go. Either way, it fits in the story.

Lynda


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]