What is canon, or what is not.(was.New Card Story (was Re: Muggles v wizards

[montavilla47]

No: HPFGUIDX 183286

> Alla:
> 
> Heee, must clarify my mindset since I was the one who originally posted 
> it on OTC.
> 
> The **only** reason I posted it on OTC is because I was not sure how 
> much people will want to get into discussing the story itself, you know?
> 
> If all that is of interest that she did write the story for charity, I 
> figured it would be more of OTC area :)
> 
> But I most definitely consider it canon.
> 
> JMO,
> 
> Alla

Montavilla47:
So, let's discuss it.  What did people think about the story?  I thought 
it was an interesting insight as to the way JKR views James and Sirius.
They're sort of like Starsky and Hutch, aren't they?  Except that they
don't contrast dark and light, mustache and afro.  They're much of a
muchness.

Of course, the depiction of muggles remains annoyingly stereotypical
of comic police in general.  Fat and stupid.

In a way, it was a bit like one of those previews you get for summer
movies that doesn't show a lot of clips, but one short, funny sketch.  Like
something you might get for an Eddie Murphy or Adam Sandler buddy
film.