[HPforGrownups] Ron/cloak question

Lee Kaiwen leekaiwen at yahoo.com
Thu Jun 26 21:05:13 UTC 2008


No: HPFGUIDX 183463

Jerri/Dan:
I know that lots of people in the past few days have been writing
about this comment of Ron's, and I don't remember who said it first,
but I am certain that it was never made, and certainly wasn't made on
the first Christmas when Harry got the cloak.

CJ:
OK, folks, to clear up the mystery, I confess to being the source, based 
on a misremembering of Ron's words, which Jerri/Dan has now quoted 
correctly. In response to Lynda's assertion that there were clues 
(pointing ultimately to the DH) throughout the series that the Cloak was 
special, I suggested the only clue I could think of was Ron's comment 
that it was in really good shape. Which obviously he didn't say. But I 
did. So I'll be going now.

CJ (slinking off)





More information about the HPforGrownups archive