GoF CH 13-16 Post DH look

terri_mares terri_mares at hotmail.com
Sun Mar 2 21:51:55 UTC 2008


No: HPFGUIDX 181840

Montavilla wrote:
>
> > "Indeed, whenever Harry saw the two of them together - at
mealtimes,
> > or when they passed  in the corridors - he had the distinct
> > impression that Snape was avoiding Moody's eye, whether magical
or
> > normal" - p.210

Terri:
I think that Moody (Barty) watched Snape because he was, like us, not
sure if Snape was on the side of the Light or the Dark.  Snape tried
to avoid Moody's eyes becuase he thought it was the real Moody.

Snape liked being Dark.  He didn't want Dumbledore to ever tell
anyone, ever, that he was protecting Harry.  See DH p. 679.  Snape
wants DD's word that he shall never reveal the best of Snape, we see
it.  He does not want Moody to know of his light side.

Montavilla wrote:
> > "We'll try that again, Potter and the rest of you, pay attention -

> > watch his eyes, that's where you see it - very good, Potter very
good
> > indeed! They'll have trouble controlling you" - p.232
> >


Terri:
When Moody was "teaching" Harry the curse, I don't think Barty was
really "teaching."  I think he was pretending to be Moody, so he used
that as an excuse to get close to Harry and learn all he could,
including, how suseptible (sp?) he was to the imperious curse. He did
after all have to keep up the appeqrence of being Proffessor Moody.
Plus, he probably found it fun toying with Harry.  Barty being so
dark was probably thinking how great it was to be able to cast the
imperious curse on his master's greatest enemy.

This is my first post ever on this list.  Please be kind.

Terri





More information about the HPforGrownups archive