Question about R.A.B and horcruxes

[Beatrice23]

No: HPFGUIDX 181874

Dear Shamil, This topic has been discussed on this site you may want 
to do a search for RAB at the top of the page to look at some of the 
comments.  I assume that you either have not read the Deathly 
Hallows, or that you are from a country where the Deathly Hollows has 
yet to be published.

Your ideas are spot on, or at least your first couple of points are.  
I don't want to ruin the last book for you, but all of these 
questions are answered within the last novel.  

Nice deductions.  I hope that you can read the last book soon.  You 
may want to exercise some caution when reading the posts on this 
site, because there are a lot of posts that will spoil the plot of 
the last book for you.

Happy reading, Beatrice

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, shamil baseet <shamil3235 at ...> 
wrote:
>
> Hey guys, I'm slightly new. By that I mean I'm new to this group 
but not to Yahoo groups and I hope this hasn't been discussed yet. I 
have been dying to know if any of it makes sense or even if I'm on to 
something.
>  
> Page 609 in the book Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince:
>  
> Harry found and figured out that the locket that he and Dumbledore 
had risked their lives for hours before Dumbledore's death was a fake 
locket with a message inside signed only with R.A.B.
>  
> Which is my first clue: obviously this Person's intials are R.A.B.
>  
> There are other clues within the short note when he pronounced
> himself a man by calling himself HE.
>  
> Second clue: this Person was a Man.
>  
> And that he knew he would be dead before the Dark Lord read the 
note.
>  
> Third clue: he is dead obviously before or during the time that
> Voldemort was creating or had finished splitting his soul.
>  
> Notice how he called him Dark Lord not Tom Riddle, not He Who Must
> Not Be Named, and not Lord Voldemort, meaning he himself was a Death
> Eater because they are the only ones who call him by that name.
>  
> Fourth clue: he is a Death Eater.
>  
> After thinking for a short time of how many Death Eaters were
> traitors obviously dead way before the most recent book I thought
> about the Blacks and Sirius' Brother Regulus.
>  
> The book didn't really say what he did to become a traitor to the
> Death Eaters but seeing how Dumbledore knew and he had said to Harry
> that he has known about these Horcruxes for years makes me think 
that
> maybe Sirius or Regulus had told him about these Horcruxes before 
one of them died.
>  
> In the end of the note it said he'd faced death in hope that 
Voldemort would be MORTAL once more so if he had gotten the locket 
and Dumbledore had gotten the Family's Ring and Harry the diary from 
his second year, could Regulus have gotten to the Cup or Something 
related to Ravenclaw or Gryffindor and of course that would only 
leave The Snake, Nagini?
> 
> shamil baseet
>