[HPforGrownups] Warrington and Apparating

[Tom Kish]

No: HPFGUIDX 181971

> DrKnow

> My question: as Hermoine ceaselessly reminds us, "you can't
> apparate into or out of Hogwarts." But Draco clearly states that
> Montague "nearly died" by apparating out of the cabinet and into
> Hogwarts. This seems like a clear violation of the magical rules
> established by JKR. So what gives? Did Montague apparate into
> Hogwarts or is there some other explanation that isn't clear to
> me after several readings of the series?

> If JKR has explained this, I'd love to see the reference. If this
> subject has been thoroughly canvassed, please refer me to the
> appropriate thread and I'd be glad to read up on this.


Draco also states that Montague would find himself in between Hogwarts and Borgin & Burkes.  Sometimes he would hear what was going on inside Hogwarts and other times he would hear what was going on inside Borgin & Burkes.  I can only assume what happened is that one of the times that the anti-apparition enchantment was taken off for apparition lessons would have allowed him to apparate out of the chest while on the Hogwarts side.

Whybnormal