The Seven Harrys (was Re: Dumbledore and other leaders WAS: Moody's death)
kempermentor
iam.kemper at gmail.com
Sat Mar 8 16:55:27 UTC 2008
No: HPFGUIDX 181979
> > Carol:
> > is "King's Cross," and even then the directors will
> > probably keep him clothed.
> CJ:
> ... at most we'll see seven Harrys in boxers in the
> ...scene; even putting Daniel in bra and panties would be a
> bit much for a children's movie (or a movie with a large underage
> viewing audience). You could, in fact, I think, just skip the
> clothes-changing entirely without serious damage to the story line;
> perhaps just having the decoys show up in Harry-like attire.
Kemper now:
In Shrek 2, Pinocchio is caught wearing a pink thong the implication
is that he likes to wear girl's underwear... and more power to him.
(Are there any other transgendered cartoon characters? I want to say
'no')
Even though it would be amusing, I'm sure many scenes will be pared
down or left out.
> > Carol:
> > Someone commented that anyone would Apparate if LV
> > tried to kill them, but the Harrys (including Mundungus)
> > weren't supposed to be in danger
> CJ:
> Certainly they weren't expecting the level of danger
> they encountered,
> but it doesn't explain why they didn't apparate out the minute they
> discovered it. In fact, I would expect Moody should have given a
> standing order to that effect before they left.
> In fact, again, I think the plan *should have* been
> (assuming they were heedful of the MoM's rule against
> apparating out of Privet Drive) to get Harry clear just far
> enough to apparate. The longer Harry (and the others)
> are in their air,
> the greater their exposure and the greater the risk. If you can't
> apparate out of the Dursleys' (...),
> then get out of their and apparate at the earliest
> possible moment.
Kemper now:
I've wondered why people don't apparate when they are being attacked
and are out numbered or skilled (The Prewets, the Potters). After
Spinner's End, I thought maybe that if a witch/wizard is near someone
that apparates that they can then follow the apparator. It is what
Bellatrix seems to do when following Narcissa. Bellatrix has no idea
where Snape lives but somehow is able to follow Narcissa (or that's my
impression).
This would be my thought on why the 7 Potters and their guardians
don't apparate. Of course, I'm most likely wrong.
Kemper
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive