Snape's potions book (was Re: Who needs Harry?)
Zara
zgirnius at yahoo.com
Sun Mar 30 22:44:22 UTC 2008
No: HPFGUIDX 182336
> SusanFullin asks:
> How come Snape's book was left in school? In HBP Harry
> gets it. I should think Snape, knowing how much he added
> and worked on it, would have taken it away. Is there
> something in canon that says textbooks must be kept at
> Hogwarts??? Thanks!
zgirnius:
There is no explanation for this. My own personal explanation, is
that Snape kept the book in the classroom for reference as a young
teacher, but over time he has reached the point that he no longer
refers to it.
I would guess that everything in it falls into one of two categories
for him. It is either something he knows by heart (so that he does
not need to look it up) or something that is outdated (in the sense
that he has discovered an even better improvement than the ones he
did, after all, invent as a teen).
If he has not so much as cracked the book open for a decade, I don't
find it hard to believe he did not bother to retrieve it from the
storage cupboard in which it was found when he took over the DADA
teaching position.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive