Lily had a chance to live thanks to Snape WAS :Re: Did Harry Notice?

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 182877

>> Carol responds:
>> Just where she's supposed to run with no wand and no Invisibility
> Cloak, I don't know. She, too, has trusted to the Fidelius Charm and
> Peter. At least, thanks to Snape, she has a chance to live, giving 
her
> sacrifice meaning. 
<SNIP of the whole post>


Alla:

I just want to say that I am deliberately snipping your whole post 
since I choose to comment only upon small part of it.

But when I see "thanks to Snape Lily has a chance to live " this 
picture always strikes me as, how to put it, well incomplete. So I 
will 
just add that I think she had a chance to die thanks to Snape first 
and 
foremost.

Alla,

who thinks that nobody who suffered in GH during that horrible night 
owes Snape anything, since what happened there in my opinion cannot 
be 
changed by any good deeds that Snape attempted to make.

That's all I want to say, for now anyways.

JMO,

Alla