Lily had a chance to live thanks to Snape WAS :Re: Did Harry Notice?

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 182879

 
> > Alla,
> > who thinks that nobody who suffered in GH during that horrible 
night 
> > owes Snape anything, since what happened there in my opinion cannot 
> > be changed by any good deeds that Snape attempted to make.
> 
> Kemper now:
> Snape repented before that fateful Halloween.
> Hasn't he atoned for his sins?

Alla:

That's completely different though IMO. Sure, he repented, but that 
will not return Lily or James from the dead, no?

That is why I say that neither one of them **owes** Snape anything.

IMO,

Alla.