OOP Chapters 11-13 Post DH look

dumbledore11214 dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Sat May 24 17:06:26 UTC 2008


No: HPFGUIDX 183009

This will be very brief post since I really do not have any specific 
quotes to quote for this post.


Chapter 11 introduces new Hat Song with suggestion of unity within 
Hogwarts. I participated in so many debates about the meaning of it 
that I am not sure that I do remember my first reaction, but I am sure 
many people do remember theirs. What was it?

I think, I think I am not hundred percent sure, but I think I certainly 
saw the possible hint that houses unity will be achieved, but I do not 
think I saw it as what must necessarily happen.

Well, we also have Umbridge, Umbridge and more Umbridge. Have fun 
discussing her :) I just want to strangle her.

Oh, and I think Hermione "Know it all" locator was working full stop. 
She **knows** from one speech that ministry interferes in Hogwarts?

Okay, then, she is Hermione after all.

We see Snape's first lesson and I wanted to strangle him too, but that 
is no surprise for anybody :-)

Boy am I glad that there is no Snape anymore in Potterverse. It was not 
enough to tell Harry that he made a mistake, eh Snape? You just needed 
to destroy his potion. I mean god forbid maybe it will look no worse 
than other students' potions?

And really, while I will always hate Snape, I certainly can see that 
rereading OOP does not let me experience positive emotions about my 
favorite adults and that I do not like.

Let's not mention Dumbledore, but when Harry comes to Mcgonagall she 
tells him to keep his head down? Is that the best you can do Minerva?

Yes, yes I KNOW Ministry interfers at Hogwarts and it is scary, but if 
that's the most you are capable of, surprised I am that Harry did not 
come to you after his awful detentions .... NOT.

Detention with Dolores.... Die Umbridge Die.


See you guys in couple weeks.

Alla








More information about the HPforGrownups archive