Headmaster for a day (was Prank WAS :Re: CHAPDISC: DH33, The Princ

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 184941

> Julie:
<SNIP>
>> And they are both right. Maybe Snape did deserve to get a scare 
for his  
> continual
> nosiness, but he didn't deserve to get a scare that might have 
become his  
> mutilation
> or death if James hadn't intervened. That's why I don't think Snape 
has  ever 
> lied about
> Sirius's motivations, because it is what Snape honestly BELIEVES--
that  
> Sirius tried
> to kill him, since it might well have turned out that way.

Alla:

And I am still missing something. I do not see after book 7 how Snape 
could honestly believe that Sirius tried to kill him, unless Snape 
majorly hypnotised himself. Of course it may have turned out that 
way. Except not without Snape going there. Again, I am holding 
Sirius' responsible here, sorry to sound like a parrot, just for his 
own actions.

Julie:
>Equally I think  
> when Sirius
> claims Snape deserved it, he means Snape deserved what he actually 
got, not  
> that
> Sirius thinks Snape deserved to die in the Prank.

Alla:

Could be, or it could be that Sirius actually thought that Snape 
deserved to die in the Shack and I am a huge Sirius' fan for those 
who do not know lol. I just do not think that Sirius telling Snape 
how to get there equals Sirius tried to kill Snape. Snape still went 
on his own.  Sirius is hugely responsible for telling the secret, 
just not for Snape going IMO.

Julie:
 Both are affected by some  
> serious
> prejudice when it comes to anything involving the other. <SNIP>

Alla:

Of course they are.

JMO,

Alla