HBP Chapters 27 - 30 post DH look

[potioncat]

No: HPFGUIDX 184535


"mmizstorge"
> I share your feelings, Marianne, to the extent that I'm mostly 
> flabbergasted by the number of postive posts I read here. If 
readers 
> have to spend so much time explaining the writer's choices to 
others 
> who have devoted an equal amount of time studying the texts, then 
it 
> can hardly be said that the writer succeeded in telling the tale in 
> a manner that was either clear or satisfying.

Potioncat:
If it's negative posts you want, go back to the first DH post. You 
won't have to read far to start finding all the negativity you could 
ever want! Most of the readers who were disappointed or displeased 
with how the series turned out have stopped posting. Some of us who 
have areas that we weren't pleased with have continued, and of 
course, some readers genuinely liked the way the books turned out.

I'll agree that there are areas where "I" think JKR dropped the ball. 
Others agree completely with canon. But I think the main reason that 
we spend so much time explaining the auhor's choice to each other, is 
because that's what HPfGU-ers do best.
;-)