HBP Chapter 20 Post DH Look
dumbledore11214
dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Sun Sep 21 02:33:52 UTC 2008
No: HPFGUIDX 184387
> Zara:
> This may seem like a nitpick, for which I apologize in advance, but I
> actually think it is an important point. Harry's willing death was
not
> needed. His unwilling death would have sufficed to eliminate the soul
> bit/Horcrux that was in Harry. It seemed to me that Albus's grand
plan
> was not about that, it was about defeating Voldemort while giving
Harry
> the best chance Albus could create to help Harry survive.
>
Alla:
Oh no problemo dear :-) I agree completely, unwilling death would have
been enough. And I am of the school that Harry completely chose to do
that himself without just blindly following Albus' plan. Meaning that
he independently thought out and decided that he would follow the plan,
because it is a good one to defend Voldemort.
So, no argument on what. Now whether Albus' plan had been about that
infdeed, I DO want to believe it, really, we had been discussing that
in the past and on my good days I do believe it, sometimes.
Other days - it is a pig for slaugher.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive