DH reread CH 6-7

dumbledore11214 dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Sat Apr 25 21:58:49 UTC 2009


No: HPFGUIDX 186313

> > Alla:
> > I love this scene, I think it is very beautifully done, I think it is romance done well. 
> 
> Zara:
> I'm glad you have discoevred this. Better late than never. <g> I think it is by far the best scene with these two characters in it, in the entire series.

Alla:

Certainly and with no chest monster in it too. Ugh. Although I do love epilogue as well, SHHHHH.


> Zara:
> I think he was planning to, until Draco messed up all his plans. What would, after all, be the logical conclusion of a night spent retrieving  Horcrux, if not showing Harry how to destroy one?

Alla:

Yes, absolutely that would be **logical** conclusion :-). The thing is though he made his will before going after Horcruxes, no? I am just thinking that he already planned to leave it to Harry after his death and I am not sure if he would have decided to change his plans.

But oh believe me I would love for you to be right.

 
> Zara:
> When have we ever heard of Hermione reading fiction? She does love books, but all the ones we hear of her reading are non-fiction. Hence - the magical properties of Snitches, yes. Beedle, no.
>

Alla:

Hm, but when did we see anybody in the WW reading fiction? I honestly do not remember, so please feel free to remind me. There are Gilderoy books of course, but he pitched them as non-fiction, no?
 It seems to me that before Beetle the Bard we do not hear much of anybody reading fiction?

If it is true, then I am not sure the fact that Hermione would rather pick up the book about snitches than magical fairy tales which is such a big part of WW culture holds any water, you know?

I mean, again obviously with introduction of these stories we are meant to think that people do read fiction in WW. Hmmm. Just thinking out loud.





More information about the HPforGrownups archive