[HPforGrownups] Re: Where Are They Now? Character Game

[Bart Lidofsky]

No: HPFGUIDX 187596

Carol responds:
> How would anyone except the students (only two that we know of, Harry and Lee Jordan) know about the quill that used their own blood to write lines? We know for a fact that Harry never reported it to McGonagall, and Dumbledore was avoiding him that year. 
Bart:
    However...

Carol:
> As far as Fudge and anyone else at the Ministry (including Scrimgeour, who must have been baffled when Harry shook his fist in his [Scrimgeour's] face),

Bart:
    Do you really think that Harry would have done that if he didn't 
believe that Scrimgeour knew damned well exactly what it was?

Carol:
> Carol, quite sure that Scrimgeour knew nothing about Umbridge's quill, much less her contemplated Crucio, or he would never have mentioned her to Harry, whom he was trying to recruit as a "mascot"

Bart:
    Can you give any logical reason why Harry and/or Dumbledore would 
not have told the Ministry about her sending the dementors? And, if 
there is one, why we weren't told about it?

    Bart