Representing Hogwarts

zfshiruba zfshiruba at yahoo.com
Wed Aug 26 05:35:57 UTC 2009


No: HPFGUIDX 187612

zfshiuba:
> > And what about Fleur? Does her performance in the lake suggest that
> > Beauxbatons places less emphasis on defense? Or, like Hogwarts, has
> > had substandard Defense instruction? The Hogwarts students learned
> > grindylows as third years, after all.

Alla:
> Fleur's performance to me was a great dissapointment. I expected her
> to be much tougher competitor.


Fleur's performance is my greatest evidence for the "representative of the school" theory. If she's the most likely student from Beauxbatons to win, Beauxbatons has no good fighters. I don't see that as being all that likely.

zfshiuba




More information about the HPforGrownups archive