[HPforGrownups] Re: Lily and Snape

[Bart Lidofsky]

No: HPFGUIDX 188657

antonia31h wrote:
> antonia31h: 
> I am surprised that Snape did not try to communicate with 
> Lily after the incident in the pensieve. I mean he was in 
> love with her and until her death he did not even want to 
> say something more to her than just apologise?
>   

Bart:
    Remember, this is just speculation on my part. The Snape's Worst 
Memory (SWM) meeting between Snape and Lily was reminiscent, at least to 
me, of the part of A CHRISTMAS CAROL where Scrooge and his fiance break 
up. It's clear from the conversation that this was a long time coming. 
Lily gave Snape a choice: Her or the Death Eaters. Snape chose the Death 
Eaters.

    Bart