Narcissa / Divorce / Kill Or Not? / Returning With Slytherins?/ Myers-Briggs

kempermentor iam.kemper at gmail.com
Mon Feb 2 03:26:17 UTC 2009


No: HPFGUIDX 185597

 
> Laura Kneazlecat54 wrote: 
> << JKR doesn't show us a single Slytherin who's a decent human being
> except for Slughorn, who has some pretty profound shortcomings, and
> maybe Snape, depending on how you feel about him. >>

> Catlady:
> Nitpick: Did she show us anything to indicate that Phineas Nigellus
> was not a decent human being, other than Sirius saying 'the most hated
> Headmaster Hogwarts ever had'? 

Kemper now:

Phineas refers to Hermione as 'The Mudblood' in The Prince's Tale
Snape cuts him off and commands, "Do not use that word!"  

Kemper





More information about the HPforGrownups archive