Slytherin's Reputation was Re: CHAPDISC: DH, EPILOGUE

Jerri&Dan Chase danjerri at madisoncounty.net
Mon Feb 2 13:57:33 UTC 2009


No: HPFGUIDX 185612

>I really wish Rowling had
> given us just ONE Syltherin whom we could point to that fought against
> Voldemort, who spoke up for the Mudbloods and the oppressed, as an example
> that not all were like that, but Rowling doesn't, and because she doesn't,
> we simply have to assume that there wasn't one.
> Shelley

What about Tonks' mother?  A Black by birth, and every Black save Sirius was 
in Syltherin.  She married a muggle born wizard, raised Tonks to be what she 
was, allowed her house to be used as a safe house for Harry in the Seven 
Potters.  She wasn't fighting in the final battle, but someone had to be 
taking care of Teddie as both his parents were at the battle.  She lost 
husband and daughter, yet stayed on good enough terms with Harry and such 
that her grandson who she raised was friendly with them.

I wish we had seen and heard more about her, but the evidence points 
strongly to her being a Syltherin and she was fighting against Voldemort, if 
not in person, certainly indirectly, but importantly.

Jerri






More information about the HPforGrownups archive