First lesson WAS: Re: Marietta, was Slytherin's Reputation

[potioncat]

No: HPFGUIDX 185818

 
> Alla:
 
> I mean, think about it. Dumbledore does not stress **anything** 
> positive in the Snape's deed, he stresses negative, he stresses that 
> Snape did it to continue hate the memory of Harry's dead father, whom 
> Harry I am sure would love to have near by. 

Potioncat:
And it was a lie. I just realized that it was a complete lie. Of 
course, DD couldn't tell Harry that Snape was protecting him to honor 
Lily....but why did DD make up that crock about Snape owing James? 
That's the worst thing he could have told Harry!

I was concerned at how quickly DD dimissed Snape's assessment of Harry. 
All the other teachers find him respectful...(something like that). It 
made me think of a younger Professor DD and the student Tom Riddle. All 
the other teachers were charmed by that boy too, but not DD.