First lesson WAS: Re: Marietta, was Slytherin's Reputation

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 185855

> jkoney:
<SNIP>
> Harry did see Snape demonstrate Expelliarmus. Who knows if it was 
> taught in class. We didn't get to see it, because Harry had already 
> figured it out. And Harry was just getting a dig in at the useless 
> Lockhart who was running away until he was stopped by two eleven 
year 
> olds.
>


Alla:

Oh, but why not. If nobody taught it in class, sure Harry learned it 
from Snape. You are right of course, though - we do not know if it 
was learned in class or not AND of course I will not give Snape 
credit for **deliberately** teaching Harry Expeliarmus LOL. He showed 
it to the whole class, well good for Harry that he figured it out. 


I mean, to run with your earlier example, I am sure there are gifted 
kids who can pick up karate moves from looking at Bruce Lee, somehow 
I think teaching those kids would not have been on his mind.


Carol, noting that Snape was thirty-one, not thirty-six, at the time
of this incident (not that it matters)
<SNIP of the whole post>

Alla:

Yes,  his behavior sounds equally bad to me  even if he was 31.