First lesson WAS: Re: Marietta, was Slytherin's Reputation
montavilla47
montavilla47 at yahoo.com
Tue Feb 17 01:53:17 UTC 2009
No: HPFGUIDX 185874
> > Montavilla47:
> > Guess how much it matters which one he belongs to. Not one bit.
> Either
> > way, it's a big disruption to the school. something that Dumbledore
> > specifically tried to avoid, and, the I figure it, Snape senses
> that the
> > sooner it's dealt with, the better.
> >
>
> jkoney:
> The disruption to the school was only temporary. After all if you
> heard that the savior of the wizarding world, someone you heard bed
> time stories about was at your school, you would have wanted to see
> him and make comments to your friends. The novelty would have worn
> off quickly just like we see it do time and again.
Montavilla47:
Or not. That sort of novelty doesn't always wear off quickly. Note
that it never quite wore off for Colin Creevey--and he continued to
bother Harry until he was petrified.
Hehe. And Ginny probably would have continued bugging Harry
for years if Hermione hadn't told her to cool it.
Jkoney:
> If Snape was at all observant during his tenure he would have known
> that things come and go rather quickly among the students. There was
> no need to step in and try to embarrass Harry the first day of his
> class to end this novelty. Unless of course there were other more
> personal reasons.
Montavilla47:
That's kind of a sweeping statement. I doubt that special chosen
saviors of the world arrived at Hogwarts every year. :)
Jkoney:
> If anyone should have stepped in it should have been the Dumbledore
> or Harry's head of house (who happens to be the assistant head). It
> doesn't appear that either of them thought it was needed.
Montavilla47:
Maybe they just weren't as bright as Snape.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive