John Granger "Looking for God in Harry Potter"/ CH 4/ Alchemy

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 185917

So in chapter 4 he argues that alchemical interpretation is very 
obvious as well and does not contradict christian signs, on the 
contrary it all goes together.

I mean I could always see this interpretation, three stages - Black, 
White, Red, but I do wonder - the fact that Hagrid did not die in the 
last book, doesn't it make a massive blow into alchemical 
interpretation? Sort of big OOOPS? I should I think wonder on Hogwarts 
professor and check out what John Granger thinks about that one day.

Although I suppose since he argues that Harry passes through three 
stages of Alchemy in every book, not one stage, I guess it could still 
stand as valid one for me.

Alla