Wand allegiance

kamion53 kersberg at chello.nl
Mon Jul 6 10:39:04 UTC 2009


No: HPFGUIDX 187245

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Damit Lazarus" <lkotur at ...> wrote:
>
> I always wondered about wand loyalty.
> When Dumbledore's Army was practicing spells in the room of
> requirement and used the Expelliarmus charm to disarm one
> another, did the wands change allegiance to the "new owner"?
> 
> Possible plot hole.
> 
> D.L.
>

this is next to one of the strongest items occuring in HP also the most sloppy executed. 
It was probably developed very late in the writing of the serie. because although taking over wands from each other occurs many times in previous books it had no consequence at all for the use or allegiance.
Ginny by the same definition should be the mistress of Harry'w wand, because she took it form Draco who took it when Dumbledore's Army was caught in book 5.

maybe she really was and did Harry fell in love with her n book 6,
but I don't think JKR has a mind as dirty as mine. 





More information about the HPforGrownups archive