Snape and Marauders WAS :Draco and Intent

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 186858

Yahoo eats a lot today.


> Potioncat:
> Who are you and what have you done with Alla?

Alla:
LOL, when had I ever call this scene not bullying? Although you know what, maybe I should not say that. Otherwise  the old post of mine will turn out saying exactly that, lol.

But not as far as I remember no, and as of today I certainly think it was bullying.

 I always disagreed that in the war with Marauders Snape was always the bullied and thought that even if author did not show details, she hinted enough to me. I thought that Marauders using Snape's curse on him smelled very much of karma and of course people who created curses like Sectusemptra to me are anything but innocent

I also  think that nobody forced Snape to go and see what Remus does at nights.

So, no I did not suddenly start to feel much sympathy for Snape, I just do not think that something which is rather simple in meaning to me, could be called something else.

Potioncat: 
> The more we discuss the James/Severus confict, the more confused I become about James. The sequence of events that I expected were so different from what turned out...It's so hard to understand how or when James became a good person.
> 
> Unless James was just as horrible in his own way as Severus was in his, and it was bravery that redeemed them both.

Alla:
Why? You think good person could not have been a bully in his youth?  And James was just as horrible as Snape? I guess to me it really does matter what views they hold and to me the fact that James joined the Order of Phoenix and Snape joined the band of terrorists is what makes one a better person than the other if nothing else.