Snape and Lucius was James and Intent And Snape

samajdar_parantap samajdar.parantap at gmail.com
Tue Jun 16 18:58:12 UTC 2009


No: HPFGUIDX 187086

> Kat:
> Why
> would he 'take a stand' when he is an intelligent man and knows this will get
> him killed? Far safer to go along with it - for now. To keep himself, and his
> wife and son safe.
> 
> 
> Kate:
> Where is the canon that Lucius was one of the Death Eaters in masks at the world
> cup? None that I've seen. <SNIP>
> 

> 
> Kate:
> Since Lucius had no real concept of what the diary was, what better way to get
> rid of more descriminating evidence (he was after all disposing of others via
> Knockturn Alley) and set up someone he must be aware is, lets say, less than
> respectful about him.
> 

The real HP interpretation :::


Actually we all interpreted HP books incorrectly. Here is the correct interpretation : 

DD was the greatest dark wizard of all times. One prophecy was made by Professor Trelawney ( the scene was omitted from the books to misguide the readers) that either a foreign dark wizard or a heir of slytherin will have any chance of ever defeating him. So DD prepared a big plan of world domination. Once he got Grindelwald out of his way, he made sweet innocent and talented Tom Riddle a scapegoat. Actually DD killed and tortured people using LVs mask – so that people believed that Tom Riddle is the actual villain. Bellatrix and Malfoys were the only people who knew the truth so DD framed those innocent people also. 

In the epilogue, actually DD is the emperor of the world and since Harry is his right hand man , all is well for him. 

Everything we see in HP books that contradicts this story is either a mistake of Harry's POV or the author's mistake or Devil trying to fool us or snurgles are behind it.

Do I need to say "In my opinion" ??

Sorry for being .. dont know what.

Parantap






More information about the HPforGrownups archive