Chamber of ....Secrets?
kempermentor
iam.kemper at gmail.com
Sat Mar 7 19:55:40 UTC 2009
No: HPFGUIDX 186026
> Lynda:
> All right, I've been following this thread and some good points have been
> brought up, but I have some questions: Why would I assume that all the
> secrets the COS has to offer were discovered by Harry and Co.? Why, in fact,
> would I assume that Tom Riddle discovered all of the secrets within the
> chamber? Why would I even want to believe either? I think, instead, I'll
> let my imagination tell me that perhaps the COS has more to offer other
> inquisitive students and possibly adults with curious minds.
Kemper now:
I suppose I would find it less likely that Tom didn't discover all there was in the Chamber. That seems out of character for him. That's not to say that there isn't more to explore. Maybe there's some more parsletongue (sp?) chambers within the main. Either way, those inquisitive students will need to speak snake (or fake it reasonably) to access the chamber. Not sure if Ron or Harry has shared the 'sound' in order to open the chamber. That sounds also OOC for Harry, though Ron could have told his kids to sound cool.
fwiw,
Kemper
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive